Welcome to Two Little Red Hens
Nestled in the heart of New York City, Two Little Red Hens is more than just a bakery; it’s a celebration of classic desserts. Known for their exquisite cakes, including the creamy New York Cheesecake, decadent Brooklyn Blackout, and rich Carrot Cake with cream cheese frosting, this charming spot offers a delightful array of flavors to satisfy any sweet tooth. Customers rave about the moistness and quality of every treat, from their seasonal Pumpkin Harvest Cake to mouthwatering cupcakes that beckon with unique flavors. At Two Little Red Hens, every bite is a reminder of the joy that baked goods can bring.
- 1641 2nd Avenue NW corner of, E 85th St, New York, NY 10028 Hotline: (212) 452-0476
Welcome to Two Little Red Hens, a charming bakery nestled in the heart of New York City at 1641 2nd Avenue on the corner of E 85th St. This delightful establishment specializes in a variety of desserts, showcasing an impressive lineup of classic cakes and cheesecakes, all crafted with care and a dash of homestyle goodness.
As soon as you step inside, the warm aromas of freshly baked goods greet you. This bakery is not just a place to satisfy your sweet tooth; it is a haven for dessert lovers. The atmosphere radiates charm, making it a perfect spot for a cozy afternoon treat or a celebratory cake. Customers often rave about the variety of flavors available, from the classic Red Velvet to the indulgent Brooklyn Blackout — a magnificent four-layer chocolate cake that is sure to please any chocolate enthusiast.
- Classic Cakes: Two Little Red Hens offers a diverse selection of cakes, like the moist Carrot Cake with walnuts and exquisite cream cheese frosting that earned accolades as the best in New York.
- Cheesecakes: Their New York Cheesecake is a true staple, featuring a perfectly toasted graham cracker crust that appeals to both locals and tourists alike.
- Seasonal Treats: Don’t miss their Pumpkin Harvest Cake or Pumpkin Cheesecake available in the fall, tantalizing your taste buds with delightful seasonal spices.
Reviews speak volumes about the quality and taste at Two Little Red Hens. Customers consistently highlight the moistness of the cakes and the rich flavors that stand out even in a city brimming with bakeries. One visitor exclaimed about the creamy, dreamy cheesecake that practically melts in your mouth, while another swooned over their light and airy cupcakes that are not just visually appealing but also a delight to devour.
While some may consider the prices slightly on the higher side, many patrons agree that the flavor and quality make every penny worth it. It’s a bakery that reminds you of the simple joys of sweets, encapsulated in every fluffy morsel and decadent bite. So whether you're a New Yorker or just passing through, make sure to stop by Two Little Red Hens for a truly delightful experience that celebrates the art of baking.

A New Yorker recommended me cheesecakes of here. I came here for only cheesecakes. But cupcakes kept calling me to get them so I got some. Cheesecake is just normal. You can find this kind of cake anywhere in NYC. Thing that made my happy ...

This is such a quaint cute little bakery. They have all kinds of incredible cake and cupcake flavors you could imagine PB, blackout chocolate, coconut, carrot cake, banana walnut and more. They are also known for their cheesecake! The ...

1 spot in NYC for carrot cake. After trying countless places, this is the best carrot cake Ive ever had. The cream cheese frosting is exquisite and the cake is always moist. They are a little pricey, but worth every single cent. For ...

Love this shop! Got their cheesecake, Brooklyn blackout cupcakemini and a slice of pie. The cupcake was good, very moist and yummy, but too sweet for me. Glad that I ...

Ok so a cheeky cheese cake stop at one of the best bakerys there is... it didnt disappoint. ...

Two little red hens is a bakery that reminds you what pastries should taste like. I had a simple coconut custard cupcake and mist say it makes me delighted I walked in. I would recommend this if you are in New York, either visiting or ...

Best cheesecake Ive ever eaten, so creamy on the inside, crust is thin and delicious on the outside, the cheese flavor is light, fresh, not overwhelming like sex in your mouth. Never fails. ...

Best cupcakes in the world!! Came all the way from Canada and made sure we stopped here. Amazing service, moist, light, and finger licking good cupcakes. The chocolate peanut butter is a must! ...