Two Little Red Hens Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Two Little Red Hens, a charming bakery nestled in the heart of New York City. Renowned for its divine array of desserts, this establishment truly showcases the art of baking. The menu boasts an enticing selection of cheesecakes, with fan-favorites like the rich Pumpkin Cheesecake and the classic New York Cheesecake. Each cheesecake features expertly crafted crusts that elevate their flavors. Guests rave about the Carrot Cake, celebrated for its moist texture and luscious cream cheese frosting—it's a must-try!
Additionally, don’t miss the delightful Bread and Cupcake offerings. Standout flavors include Chocolate Peanut Butter and Brooklyn Blackout. Every bite at Two Little Red Hens promises a sweet escape, making it a quintessential stop for dessert lovers visiting NYC. Whether you’re indulging in a slice or treating yourself to a cupcake, the experience is always sublime.
Classic Cakes
Brooklyn Blackout
Four layers of chocolate cake, three layers of chocolate pudding filling & fudge frosting
Red Velvet
A light red butter cake with a hint of cocoa & homestyle cream cheese frosting
Yellow Cake / Chocolate Cake
Two layers of classic yellow cake or chocolate cake with your choice of Swiss vanilla buttercream with spiral frosting & decorative sprinkles, or homestyle Chocolate fudge frosting & decorative sprinkles
Carrot
A carrot spice cake with walnuts & cream cheese frosting, decorated with classic buttercream carrots
Banana
Available in winter, spring & summer. A moist banana cake made with fresh bananas & homestyle cream cheese frosting
Pumpkin Harvest
Available in the fall. A super-moist pumpkin spice cake with apricot pumpkin cream cheese frosting & buttercream fall leaf decoration
Lemon Gingerbread
Available in December. A classic gingerbread cake with homestyle lemon cream cheese frosting
New York Cheesecake*
Our classic New York cheesecake with a toasted graham cracker crust
Cherry Cheesecake
Our classic New York Cheesecake with a Michigan sour cherry topping
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Available fall. A smooth & rich spiced pumpkin cheesecake with a molasses graham cracker crust confection
Cheesecake
Classics
Yellow or Chocolate
with your choice of: Swiss vanilla buttercream (less sweet & silky smooth) Chocolate fudge frosting
Marble
("black & white") with a swirl of chocolate fudge & Swiss vanilla buttercream
Pumpkin
pumpkin harvest cake with pumpkin apricot cream cheese frosting (autumn)
Seasonal
Filled
Peanut Butter Fudge Swirl*
chocolate cake, PB buttercream filling, PB chocolate fudge swirl frosting
Boston Cream
chiffon cake, vanilla pastry cream filling, fudge &chocolate glaze with chocolate shavings (in-store only)
Key Lime
chiffon cake, key lime cream filling, key lime-infused whipped cream with fresh lime zest (in-store only)
Coconut Cream
chiffon cake, coconut cream filling, coconut whipped cream with toasted coconut shavings (in-store only)
Eggnog Bavarian
Chiffon cake, eggnog Bavarian cream, whipped cream & fresh nutmeg (December). Seasonal
Irish Cream
Chocolate chiffon cake, Irish cream filling (made with Bailey's™), chocolate fudge & glaze (March). Seasonal
Chilled 'N' Filled
Winter Pies
Apple
A classic "double crust" apple pie made with a seasonal blend of apples & a dash of spice
Apple Crumb
Our classic apple pie with a cinnamon oatmeal & brown sugar crumb topping
Cherry
Two varieties of Michigan sour cherries with a classic lattice crust & checkered with crumble topping
Lemon Chess
A sweet southern custard pie
Pecan / Chocolate Pecan
A Southern tradition with toasted pecans & a sweet buttery filling with (or without) rich chunks of Callebaut 60/40 chocolate
Chocolate Mousse
Rich Chocolate mousse made with Callebaut semi-sweet chocolate, fresh whipped cream & chocolate shavings